2000   Tyler Bacon   Robert Morris University
    Duane Dacres   University of Wisconsin-Parkside
    Kenny Richardson Fairmont State College
       
2001   Marques Ivy   University of South Alabama
    Phil Calvert   San Jose State University
    Pawel Stasiak   Washington State University
    Ryan Lane   Emporia State University
               
2002   Bobby Carter   Western Illinois University
    Kendrick Jackson Southwest Baptist University
    Solomon Jones   South Florida University
               
2003   D’Andre McGrew   Georgia State University
    Dramane Diarra   Kansas State University
    Darrell Freeman   Flager University
    Josh Eilert    Kansas State University
               
2004   Garrett Farha   St. Francis University
    Martel Mahon   University of Southern Illinois
    Kenny Simelton   University of New Orleans
    Omar Guinea   Henderson State University
    Josh Campbell   Kansas State University
    Jeremy Thayer   Kansas Newman College
    Landon Steele   Kansas Newman College
               
2005   Keddric Mays   Tennessee-Chattanooga
    Adam Vogelsberg Middle Tennessee State
    Kevin Kelley   Southwestern College
    Manourou Gakou Creighton University
               
2006   Reed Hein   Washburn University
    Mike Lytle   University of West Georgia
    James Williams   St. Bonaventure University
    Geremey Gibson   Regis University  
    Egan Grafel   Northern Illinois University
    B.J. Nimocks   Maryland Eastern Shore
    Mamadou Sy   Murray State University
               
2007   Mike Allen   Ohio University  
    Bret Shaw   Baker University  
    Vince Thompkins Mid-America Nazarene College
    Heath Baird   Baker University  
    Cassin Diggs   University of Pittsburgh
    Justin Houser   South Carolina Upstate Univ.
    Ricky Jackson   Duquesne University
               
2008   Rudy Meo   Univ. of California – Riverside
    Kendall Russell   Western Carolina University
    Dallas Blocker   Youngstown State University
    Justin Purtee   Haskell College  
    Kissom Moss   Jamestown College
    Girod Adams   Stephen F. Austin University
    Tyler Antenen   Kansas Wesleyan University
               
2009   Jemal Farmer   University of Arkansas
    Andrew Taylor   Drury University  
    Chris  Tate   Ottawa University
    Chris White-Ready Drury University  
    Oleg Kovalov   Indiana-Purdue Fort Wayne Univ.
    Devon Peterson   Kansas State University
               
2010   Antonio Stewart   Ottawa University
    Adrian Herrera   Pittsburg State University
    Eric Ray   Pittsburg State University
    Drake Green   Pittsburg State University
    Eric Marshall   Pittsburg State University
    Freddy Asprilla   Kansas State University
               
2011   Mohamed Fall   Montana State University
    Omari Lawrence   Kansas State University
    Jordan Herrera   North Carolina A & T
    Ben Steinlage   Baker University  
    Todd Johnston   Baker University  
    Brandon Newton   Mid-America Nazarene University
               
2012   Richard Carter   Drake University  
    Onzie Branch   Gardner-Webb University
    Derek Cooke   University of Wyoming
    Devon Branch   University of Oregon
    Alex Williams   Pittsburg State University
               
2013   Alioune Mboup   Henderson State University
    Gerrae Williams   Mercyhurst University
    Edward Dyson   Austin Peay University
    Isaiah Anaekwe   St. Mary’s University
    Connor McDaniel Baker University  
    Marcus Fillyaw   Southern Illinois University
               
2014   Marvin Smith   South Carolina Upstate
    Shaun Stewart   Youngstown State University
    Lionel Gomis   Robert Morris University
    Rodney Pryor   Robert Morris University
    Assane Diop   Austin Peay University
    Emeka Okoronkwo Dordt University  
    Jeremiah Brooks Ottawa University
               
2015   Alan Garcia   Ottawa University
    Creighton Brinker Pittsburg State University
    Ridell Camidge   UNC Charlotte  
    Devon Thomas   Texas Tech University